The God Beyond Belief

1. Front Matter

   Pages I-XVII

   PDF

2. Introduction

   Pages 1-16

3. Background to the Problem of Evil

   Pages 17-45

4. Rowe's Evidential Arguments from Evil

   Pages 47-76

5. What No Eye Has Seen: The Epistemic Foundations of Wykstra's CORNEA Critique

   Pages 77-98

6. CORNEA Applied to Rowe's Evidential Argument

   Pages 99-134

7. Further Objections to Rowe's Noseeum Assumption

   Pages 135-161

8. In Support of the Inference from Inscrutable to Pointless Evil

   Pages 163-188

9. The Problem of Divine Hiddenness

   Pages 189-226

10. Meta-Theodicy: Adequacy Conditions for Theodicy

    Pages 227-250

11. Theodicy Proper, or Casting Light on the Ways of God: Horrendous Moral Evil

    Pages 251-274

12. Theodicies for Natural Evil

    Pages 275-302

13. The Compatibility of Gratuitous Evil with Theism

    Pages 303-331

14. Conclusion: Is Rowe's Evidential Argument Successful?

    Pages 333-345

15. Back Matter

    Pages 347-373

    PDF

For quite some time I have corresponded with Nick Trakakis, a very t- ented young philosopher at Monash University in Australia. He was c- pleting a manuscript on the problem of evil. Although we’ve never met, I’ve come to greatly admire his philosophical ability, even, or I hope particularly, when he notes weaknesses, if not outright mistakes, in my own writings on this topic. His knowledge of the relevant literature is nothing short of extraordinary. I am deeply impressed by the clarity and quality of his wr- ing, his measured judgments, as well as his philosophical ability. In this volume Trakakis begins with my 1979 paper, “The Problem of Evil and Some Varieties of Atheism,” sets forth the evidential argument from evil, and considers the large body of literature developed in response to that argument. He examines and evaluates with great care the objections raised by Wykstra, Howard-Snyder, Durston,Alston, and others, along with my responses to those forceful objections. Noting the importance of the assumption that if there are God-justifying goods for horrendous human and animal suffering then it is likely that humans would have some awareness of what those justifying goods might be, Trakakis carefully evaluates the lit- ature bearing on this crucial issue, including, of course, the significance of what is commonly known as the problem of divine hiddenness, and the line of response proposed by the sceptical theists – philosophers who are theists but sceptical of arguments against theism.

• God
• Philosophy of religion
• Problem of evil
• Religion
• Theodicy
• William L. Rowe

• Monash University, Melbourne, Australia

  Nick Trakakis

Policies and ethics