Need-Based Distributive Justice

1. Front Matter

   Pages i-vii

   PDF

2. Perspectives for a Theory of Need-Based Distributive Justice

   • Stefan Traub

   Pages 1-20

3. Need-Based Justice from the Perspective of Philosophy

   • Mark Siebel, Thomas Schramme

   Pages 21-58

4. Identifying Needs: The Psychological Perspective

   • Adele Diederich

   Pages 59-89

5. Need-Based Justice: A Sociological Perspective

   • Bernhard Kittel

   Pages 91-131

6. Collective Decisions on Need-Based Distribution: A Political Science Perspective

   • Frank Nullmeier, Tanja Pritzlaff-Scheele, Kai-Uwe Schnapp, Markus Tepe

   Pages 133-159

7. Need-Based Justice and Distribution Procedures: The Perspective of Economics

   • Andreas Nicklisch, Fabian Paetzel

   Pages 161-189

8. Towards a Theory of Need-Based Justice

   • Frank Nullmeier

   Pages 191-208

This book explores the foundations and potential of a theory of need-based distributive justice, supported by experimental evidence. The core idea is that need-based distributive justice may have some legitimatory advantages over other important principles of distribution, like equality and equity, and therefore involves less dispute over the distribution and redistribution of scarce resources.

In seven chapters, eleven scholars from the fields of philosophy, psychology, sociology, political science and economics outline the normative and positive building blocks of such a theory by critically reviewing the literature on distributive justice from their respective disciplinary perspectives. They address important theoretical and practical issues concerning the rationality of needs identification at the individual level and the recognition of needs at the societal level. They also investigate whether and how the dynamics of distribution procedures that allocate resourcesaccording to the need principle leads to social stability, focusing on the economic incentives that arise from need-based redistribution. The final chapter provides a synthesis and outlines a framework for a theory of justice based on ten hypotheses derived from the insights presented.

• Distributive justice
• Need-based justice
• Social justice
• Economic fairness
• Distribution procedures
• Laboratory experiments
• Needs identification
• Social stability

• Department of Economics and Social Sciences, Helmut Schmidt University Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany

  Stefan Traub

• Department of Economic Sociology, University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria

  Bernhard Kittel

Stefan Traub is a Professor of Behavioral Economics at Helmut-Schmidt-University in Hamburg (Germany). He is the spokesperson of the research group “Need-based justice and distributive procedures” (FOR 2104) funded by the German Research Foundation (DFG), the Austrian Science Fund (FWF) and the Swiss National Fund (SNF). His research focuses on the economics of inequality and distribution, social preferences, and decision making under risk. He has published in leading journals, like the Journal of Public Economics, Games and Economic Behavior, and European Economic Review.  


Bernhard Kittel is a Professor of Economic Sociology at the University of Vienna (Austria) and principal investigator of the research group “Need-based justice and distributive procedures” (FOR 2104). His current main research interests are justice attitudes, group decision-making, and marginal groups in the labor market. He has published papers in various leading journals, most recently in Plos One, Social Science Research, the Journal of Public Economics, Political Research Quarterly, the Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, and Sociological Inquiry.

Policies and ethics