The Dual Nature of Legitimacy in the Prison Environment

1. Front Matter

   Pages i-xxiii

   PDF

2. Introduction

   • Rok Hacin, Gorazd Meško

   Pages 1-8

3. Punishment and Legitimacy

   • Rok Hacin, Gorazd Meško

   Pages 9-15

4. Prison Actors

   • Rok Hacin, Gorazd Meško

   Pages 17-21

5. The Dual Model of Legitimacy in the Prison Environment

   • Rok Hacin, Gorazd Meško

   Pages 23-31

6. The Slovenian Prison System

   • Rok Hacin, Gorazd Meško

   Pages 33-39

7. Methodology

   • Rok Hacin, Gorazd Meško

   Pages 41-45

8. Qualitative Study of Legitimacy in Slovenian Prisons

   • Rok Hacin, Gorazd Meško

   Pages 47-68

9. Quantitative Study of Legitimacy in Slovenian Prisons

   • Rok Hacin, Gorazd Meško

   Pages 69-84

10. Discussion and Conclusion

    • Rok Hacin, Gorazd Meško

    Pages 85-94

11. Back Matter

    Pages 95-96

    PDF

This book explores the dual nature of legitimacy in prison. It examines the inter-connectivity between audience perception of legitimacy (the prisoners’ perception) and the power-holders’ perception of legitimacy (the prison staff perception). It defines legitimacy in this scenario as the ability of prison workers to implement their authority in an honest, lawful, and just manner, while prisoners acknowledge their status as eligible power-holders who deserve to be obeyed and comply with their decisions.

Using mixed methods of qualitative and quantitative research, data were collected in all Slovenian prisons as well as a correctional home. The volume discusses the various factors influencing prisoner's perspective of legitimacy, and recommends avenues for further research.

This work will be of interest to researchers in criminology and criminal justice, particularly with an interest in prison and incarceration, or with an interest in Eastern Europe. It will alsobe of interest to those studying legitimacy within the criminal justice system more generally, and related fields such as sociology, law enforcement, and organizational psychology.

Utilizing an in–depth and longitudinal study of legitimacy in Slovenian prisons, Hacin and Meško shed light on legitimacy’s dual nature with an exquisite research design that removes any ambiguity about its essential nature in achieving prison order and correctional environments more conducive to rehabilitation. […] Overall, the book is an excellent contribution to penological theory, research, and practice. A monograph and case study of a post-modern and post-socialist prison system, it offers a lens for re–examining the mass incarceration models of western prisons for cross–cultural comparisons of prison legitimacy.

-Rosemary L. Gido, Professor Emerita, Department of Criminology and Criminal Justice, Indiana University of Pennsylvania, USA

 

This book studies legitimacy in prisoners and among prison staff through the lens of procedural justice theory, focusing on the context of Slovenia. The book is a must–read for scholars who are theoretically and methodologically interested in testing and applying procedural justice theory. Rarely, both prison staff and prisoners are studied in the same inquiry. This is the added value. The results have value for prison policy. This book will be of interest to scholars in criminology and criminal justice, as well as political science and public policy.

- Lieven Pauwels, Professor, Department of Criminology, Criminal Law and Social Law, Ghent University, Belgium

 

The now global epistemic community for the study of criminal justice and criminology requires that scholars everywhere be in frequent communication, and that they engage in the testing of concepts that are of potential universal application in democratic countries seeking to build just and efficacious public institutions. The time is here for comparative criminal justice research of high quality to be undertaken, and this book represents exemplary scholarship in this regard.

For those scholars from around the world interested in determining the potential and limitations of the theory of procedural justice as applied in the corrections setting, this book represents a “must read” for you. It presents findings from a comprehensive, mixed–methods study of how the core concepts of the theory of procedural justice can be insightfully explored within correctional institutions. The study done in the progressive, highly regarded setting of the Slovenian prison system – carried out with inmates, prison staff (corrections officers and rehabilitation services personnel) and administrators – serves as an excellent template for replication in other countries. The interpretation of findings made by two scholars of remarkable experience and profound knowledge add greatlyto the value of this book. For scholars doing worthwhile research into the challenges of building and maintaining just and capable criminal justice systems in democratic countries, this book will inform and inspire you.

- Nicholas Lovrich, Research Professor Emeritus, Department of Criminal Justice and Criminology, Washington State University, Pullman, USA

• legitimacy
• self-legitimacy
• procedural justice
• use of force
• prison
• corrections
• prison staff
• Slovenia
• perception of legitimacy
• incarceration
• criminal justice

“Utilizing an in–depth and longitudinal study of legitimacy in Slovenian prisons, Hacin and Meško shed light on legitimacy’s dual nature with an exquisite research design that removes any ambiguity about its essential nature in achieving prison order and correctional environments more conducive to rehabilitation. […] Overall, the book is an excellent contribution to penological theory, research, and practice. A monograph and case study of a post-modern and post-socialist prison system, it offers a lens for re–examining the mass incarceration models of western prisons for cross–cultural comparisons of prison legitimacy.” (Rosemary L. Gido, Professor Emerita, Department of Criminology and Criminal Justice, Indiana University of Pennsylvania, USA)

“This book studies legitimacy in prisoners and among prison staff through the lens of procedural justice theory, focusing on the context of Slovenia. The book is a must–read for scholars who are theoretically and methodologically interested in testing and applying procedural justice theory. Rarely, both prison staff and prisoners are studied in the same inquiry. This is the added value. The results have value for prison policy. This book will be of interest to scholars in criminology and criminal justice, as well as political science and public policy.” (Lieven Pauwels, Professor, Department of Criminology, Criminal Law and Social Law, Ghent University, Belgium)

“For those scholars from around the world interested in determining the potential and limitations of the theory of procedural justice as applied in the corrections setting, this book represents a “must read” for you. It presents findings from a comprehensive, mixed–methods study of how the core concepts of the theory of procedural justice can be insightfully explored within correctional institutions. The study done in the progressive, highly regarded setting of the Slovenian prison system – carried out with inmates, prison staff (correctionsofficers and rehabilitation services personnel) and administrators – serves as an excellent template for replication in other countries. The interpretation of findings made by two scholars of remarkable experience and profound knowledge add greatly to the value of this book. For scholars doing worthwhile research into the challenges of building and maintaining just and capable criminal justice systems in democratic countries, this book will inform and inspire you.” (Nicholas Lovrich, Research Professor Emeritus, Department of Criminal Justice and Criminology, Washington State University, Pullman, USA)

• Faculty of Criminal Justice and Security, University of Maribor, Maribor, Slovenia

  Rok Hacin, Gorazd Meško

Rok Hacin, Ph.D., is an Assistant Professor of Criminology at the Faculty of Criminal Justice and Security, University of Maribor, Slovenia. Faculty of Criminal Justice and Security, University of Maribor, Slovenia. His research interest includes the legitimacy of criminal justice, penal statistics, penal policy, prison subculture, treatment of prisoners, crime mapping, and fear of crime. He has published several articles and book chapters in international and peer-reviewed publications. He has participated in a research project on Legitimacy and legality of policing, criminal justice and execution of penal sanctions (2013–2016) and a research program on Security and safety in local communities (2015–2024).

Gorazd Meško, Ph.D., is a Full Professor of Criminology and a Head of Institute of Criminal Justice and Security Research at the Faculty of Criminal Justice and Security, University of Maribor, Slovenia. He has been a President of the European Society of Criminology and an International Ambassador of the British Society of Criminology. His research interests include comparative criminology, penal policy, legitimacy of criminal justice, crime prevention, policing, environmental criminology, victimization, and cyber-crime. He has recently completed a national research project on Legitimacy and legality of policing, criminal justice and execution of penal sanctions (2013–2016) and is currently a lead researcher of a research program on Security and safety in local communities (2015–2024). He has recently co-edited a book on Trust and Legitimacy in Criminal Justice: European Perspectives (Springer, Meško and Tankebe 2015).

Policies and ethics