Edward Channing and the Great Work

1. Front Matter

   Pages I-XI

   PDF

2. The Great Channing

   1. Front Matter

      Pages 1-1

      PDF

   2. Edward Channing: A Biographical Sketch

      • Davis D. Joyce

      Pages 3-15

   3. The Great Channing

      • Davis D. Joyce

      Pages 16-34

3. The Great Work

   1. Front Matter

      Pages 35-35

      PDF

   2. The Planting of a Nation in the New World

      • Davis D. Joyce

      Pages 37-57

   3. A Century of Colonial History

      • Davis D. Joyce

      Pages 58-75

   4. The American Revolution

      • Davis D. Joyce

      Pages 76-95

   5. Federalists and Republicans

      • Davis D. Joyce

      Pages 96-114

   6. The Period of Transition

      • Davis D. Joyce

      Pages 115-135

   7. The War for Southern Independence, and the End of the Great Work

      • Davis D. Joyce

      Pages 136-163

4. Other Works

   1. Front Matter

      Pages 165-165

      PDF

   2. Textbooks

      • Davis D. Joyce

      Pages 167-178

   3. Miscellaneous Writings

      • Davis D. Joyce

      Pages 179-188

5. An Evaluation

   1. Front Matter

      Pages 189-189

      PDF

   2. Edward Channing, Historian

      • Davis D. Joyce

      Pages 191-212

6. Back Matter

   Pages 213-231

   PDF

Twenty years after Edward Channing's death in 1931, historians differed rather widely in their evaluation of his work. A British author, surveying American historiography since 1890, was quite critical of Channing's major contribution, the six-volume History of the United States, contending that it "won only a contemporary reputation which is not wearing well. "l Referring specifically to the second volume of the History, this writer stated his feeling that it "added little of substance to what was to be found in earlier works," and that it "was so partisan as sometimes to be quite misleading. "2 Quite a different view was expressed by an American historian writing in the same year. He felt that Channing seemed "assured of a niche in the his­ torians' Hall of Fame as one of the giants of American historiography. "3 Many of Channing's findings were new, this writer emphasized, and had been useful to other historians. He concluded that Channing's History "wears well twenty years after his death," and, indeed, "remains one of the major accomplishments in the field of American historical writing. '" Some support is given to the latter interpretation by a poll of historians, once again dated 1952, to determine preferred works in American history published between 1920 and 1935. Channing's History finished eighth, fol­ lowing only the works of Parrington, Turner, Webb, Beard, Andrews, 5 Becker, and Phillips.

• American History
• Edward Perkins Channing
• USA
• american revolution
• colonial history
• historiography
• the Great Work

Policies and ethics