Environmental Value Transfer: Issues and Methods

1. Front Matter

   Pages I-X

   PDF

2. Review of Methods for Value Transfer

   • S. Navrud, R. Ready

   Pages 1-10

3. Benefit and Informational Transfers

   • D. Brookshire, J. Chermak

   Pages 11-22

4. Correspondence and Convergence in Benefit Transfer Accuracy: Meta-Analytic Review of the Literature

   • R. Rosenberger, T. Phipps

   Pages 23-43

5. Transferring Landscape Values: How And How Accurately?

   • J. M. L. Santos

   Pages 45-75

6. Morbidity Value Transfer

   • R. Ready, S. Navrud

   Pages 77-88

7. Uncertainty, Benefit Transfers and Physical Models: A Middle Rio Grande Valley Focus

   • D. Brookshire, J. Chermak, R. Desimone

   Pages 89-109

8. Estimating the Economic Value of Improvements in River Ecology Using Choice Experiments: An application to the water framework directive

   • Nick Hanley, Robert E. Wright, Begona Alvarez-Farizo

   Pages 111-130

9. Contrasting conventional with multi-level modeling approaches to meta-analysis: Expectation consistency in UK woodland recreation values

   • Ian J. Bateman, Andrew P. Jones

   Pages 131-160

10. Benefit Transfer Using Meta-Analysis In Recreation Economic Valuation

    • R. Shrestha, R. Rosenberger, J. Loomis

    Pages 161-177

11. Benefit Value Transfers Conditional On Site Attributes: Some Evidence Of Reliability From Forest Recreation In Ireland

    • R. Scarpa, W.G. Hutchinson, S.M. Chilton, J. Buongiorno

    Pages 179-206

12. Can use and Non-use Values Be Transferred Across Countries?

    • D. KristÒFersson, S. Navrud

    Pages 207-225

13. The Application of Bayesian Methods in Benefit Transfer

    • C. León, R. León, F. Vázquez-Polo

    Pages 227-239

14. Improving the Practice of Benefits Transfer: A Preference Calibration Approach

    • S. Pattanayak, V. K. Smith, G. Van Houtven

    Pages 241-260

15. How Much Is Enough? The Value Of Information From Benefit Transfers In A Policy Context

    • D. Barton

    Pages 261-282

16. Lessons Learned for Environmental Value Transfer

    • S. Navrud, R. Ready

    Pages 283-290

The transfer of environmental values in time and space has increased rapidly with the widespread use of cost benefit analysis in project evaluation and regulatory assessments over the last three decades. Over the last 15 years, other policy uses like environmental costing, greening of systems of national accounts and natural resource damage assessments after oil spills and other pollution accidents have also contributed to the increased demand for environmental values. However, most early transfers were conducted in an uncritical manner, often lacking sound theoretical, statistical and empirical basis, and did not question the validity and reliability of the transferred values. What appears to be the first environmental value transfer exercise estimated damages, and illustrates the point that what is generally termed benefit transfer, should rather be termed value transfer in order to capture both reductions and increments in environmental quality and natural resources. This first attempt to transfer environmental values seems to be the calculation of lost recreational value from the Hell’s Canyon hydroelectric project more than 30 years ago, as described by John V. Krutilla and Anthony C. Fisher in their book (Chapters 5 and 6): The Economics of Natural Environments Studies in the Valuation of Commodity and Amenity Resources. (John Hopkins Press, Baltimore, 1975). The first large-scale user of value transfer was the USDA Forest Service.

• benefit transfer
• contingent valuation
• cost-benefit analysis
• ecology
• environmental policy
• stated preference

From the reviews:

"This book provides ample evidence assessing the reliability of the benefit transfer method for different environmental improvements. … it gives the reader a thorough exposition of the ongoing research in the area of value transfer. For readers interested in different case studies assessing the accuracy of the benefit transfer methods, this book is most definitely recommended as it deals with some well-performed case studies using current state-of-the-art procedures from the benefit transfer literature." (Mitesh Kataria, European Review of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 35 (2), 2008)

• Department of Economics and Resource Management, Norwegian University of Life Sciences, Norway

  Ståle Navrud

• Department of Agricultural Economics and Rural Sociology, Pennsylvania State University, Pennsylvania

  Richard Ready

Policies and ethics