Economics As Discourse

1. Front Matter

   Pages i-xi

   PDF

2. Introduction

   • Warren J. Samuels

   Pages 1-14

3. Economics as a Postmodern Discourse

   • Jack Amariglio

   Pages 15-64

4. A Hermeneutic Approach to Economics: If Economics is Not Science, and if it is not Merely Mathematics, then What could it be?

   • Raymond Benton Jr.

   Pages 65-99

5. Economics as Ideology

   • Robert Heilbroner

   Pages 101-128

6. The Textbook Presentation of Economic Discourse

   • Arjo Klamer

   Pages 129-165

7. Hermeneutics, Subjectivity, and the Lester/Machlup Debate: Toward a More Anthropological Approach to Empirical Economics

   • Don Lavoie

   Pages 167-187

8. Walras’ “Economics and Mechanics”: Translation, Commentary, Context

   • Philip Mirowski, Pamela Cook

   Pages 189-224

9. Deconstructing Robert Lucas

   • Jane Rossetti

   Pages 225-256

10. Back Matter

    Pages 257-258

    PDF

1 Warren J. Samuels The study of economics as discourse requires a perspective that focuses on the relationships among knowledge (or truth), discourse (or lan­ guage), and meaning. Central to this task is the recognition that the con­ duct of economic analysis uses words and that words embody meanings that are applied to the object of study, but do not necessarily derive from that object although they define that object for us. Knowledge Economists are engaged in efforts to understand and explain the econ­ omy. In the pursuit of this knowledge they have attempted to make coherent the respect(s) in which belief is to be accepted as knowledge, or the sense(s) in which this knowledge has the quality of "truth. " The field of methodology in economics parallels the fields of epistemology and philosophy of science in the attempt to make sense of and to prescribe the terms on which efforts at knowledge may be accepted as "true," or the terms on which statements can be accepted as "knowledge. " The conduct of such methodological inquiry typically treats economics as a science 1 2 ECONOMICS AS DISCOURSE engaged in the pursuit of truth as an epistemological category - though there have almost always been economists who were skeptical of the status of economics as a science, and the pursuit of knowledge is only one of three putative function of economics, the other two being psychic balm and social control.

• economics
• mathematics
• mechanics
• science and technology

Policies and ethics